“Hundreds of songs were penned in the Lennon‑McCartney golden era… but not all made it onto Beatles records. Yet many became major hits—recorded by others. Today, we dig into those almost-Beatles tracks and the surprising stories behind them.”
Brian Epstein encouraged Lennon‑McCartney to write songs for his other acts (Cilla Black, Billy J. Kramer, the Fourmost) to build their careers.
Many songs were deemed unsuitable stylistically or thematically for Beatles LPs, despite being high quality.
Here are some rejected lennon-mccartney songs that could have been in a Beatles Albums but were given to another artists which also became major hits.
“Bad to Me”
In July 1963, John Lennon gave “Bad to Me” to Billy J. Kramer & the Dakotas—a rising act also managed by Brian Epstein. Though written by Lennon (with some input from McCartney), The Beatles never released it themselves. Instead, George Martin produced Kramer’s version, crafting a polished, Beatlesque arrangement that helped it soar to No. 1 on the UK charts. While The Beatles did record a demo, it remained unreleased until decades later, when it surfaced on Live at the BBC, offering fans a glimpse of what could’ve been another Fab Four classic.
“A World Without Love”
Written by a teenage Paul McCartney while living in the Asher household, “A World Without Love” was one of the earliest songs he finished—complete with its now-famous opening line: “Please lock me away…” But Paul felt it wasn’t right for The Beatles. Fortunately, his girlfriend Jane Asher’s brother, Peter Asher, had just formed a duo with Gordon Waller. McCartney offered the song to them, and under George Martin’s guidance, Peter and Gordon’s version became a massive hit—reaching No. 1 on both the UK and US charts in 1964. It was the first Lennon-McCartney composition to top the charts for another artist
One of few Lennon‑McCartney songs to hit #1 without Beatles performing.
“From a Window” & “I’ll Keep You Satisfied”
In 1963, Lennon and McCartney gifted Billy J. Kramer & the Dakotas two more songs: “From a Window” and its B-side “I’ll Keep You Satisfied.” Both tunes carried that unmistakable early-Beatles charm—simple hooks, youthful lyrics, and George Martin’s polished production. “From a Window” became a Top 10 hit in the UK, while “I’ll Keep You Satisfied,” released earlier, reached No. 4. Though the Beatles never officially released versions themselves, these songs showed how even their “hand-me-downs” could become pop hits, especially when delivered with the Beatles’ signature style and studio touch.
“Hello Little Girl” – The Fourmost
“Hello Little Girl” was one of John Lennon’s earliest compositions, dating back to his teenage years. The Beatles performed it at their infamous Decca audition in 1962, but it remained unreleased by the band. Instead, their Liverpool contemporaries The Fourmost—managed by Brian Epstein—released it in 1963. Produced by George Martin, the single captured Lennon’s catchy, Everly Brothers–inspired pop style and climbed into the UK Top 10, giving The Fourmost their biggest hit and showcasing Lennon’s songwriting reach beyond the Beatles’ own catalog.
“Love of the Loved” – Cilla Black (1963)
“Love of the Loved” was one of Paul McCartney’s early compositions, originally performed by the Beatles during their Cavern Club days and even recorded at their Decca audition. Though the Beatles never officially released it, the song found new life through Cilla Black—another Liverpool artist discovered by Brian Epstein. Produced by George Martin, Cilla’s version became her debut single in 1963 and reached No. 35 on the UK charts. It marked the beginning of her successful career, and the track remains one of the few Lennon–McCartney songs first given to a female artist.
These cases show: even Beatles’ rejects held rock‑and‑roll gold.
It highlights Lennon‑McCartney’s songwriting prowess and the band’s internal selection pressures.
Many of these tracks gained identity and success in interpreters’ hands.
“Which of these Lennon-McCartney songs is your favorite? Which do you think would’ve sounded best performed by The Beatles themselves?”